AOP, laminating, and concentrated butters: technical differences
AOP, laminating, or concentrated butter: know which one to choose for each product and how to adapt your recipe when you switch butters.
Table of contents(6 chapters)
82%, 84%, 99.8%: comparing what each butter actually contributes
The fat percentage tells you what the butter contributes to the formula. To choose a product, also examine its plasticity, its taste, and the uses specified by the manufacturer.
| Product | What 500 g contributes | Key point |
|---|---|---|
| Butter, 82% fat | 410 g of fat | May be intended for mixing in or for lamination, depending on the product |
| Butter, 84% fat | 420 g of fat | Use and preparation to be checked on the spec sheet |
| Concentrated butter, 99.8% fat | 499 g of fat | Contributes very little water; uses depend on the technical product chosen |
The rest consists of water and nonfat milk solids. Check the detailed composition to know what they contribute; also include any salt in the formula calculation.
To replace one product with another, compare its spec sheet with that of the planned ingredient. Keeping the same weight can change the fat-to-water balance and the texture, even if both products are called butter.
AOP butters: origin, taste, and technical suitability
AOP butters, including Charentes-Poitou and Isigny, combine an origin with production conditions specific to their appellation. For the pastry chef, this means a product identity to assess by taste and in production.
The AOP tells you about origin; what the product is designed for specifies its technical use. Some AOP butter sheets are designed for lamination, while other formats are offered for mixing in. Check these indications on the product’s spec sheet.
- For buttercream or a finishing preparation, compare the aroma, the melt, and the texture you get.
- For a croissant or puff pastry, also examine plasticity and how the butter holds up during your process.
- For a brioche or a loaf cake, also judge the result after baking, at the time it is usually eaten.
The ripening of the cream and the manufacturing process contribute to the butter’s profile. Compare the characteristics stated for each product, then assess its aroma, color, and texture in your own products.
Good to know
Compare the butters under the same tasting conditions, then in the finished product. Also check the stated use: block for mixing in, sheet for lamination, or another technical product.
Choosing an 82% or 84% laminating butter
The difference that matters for lamination shows up under pressure: the butter must stretch into an even layer with the dough. An 82% laminating butter may be suitable; an 84% product may offer other characteristics, to be examined under the same conditions.
Organize the comparison around three criteria:
- Preparation: the manufacturer’s instructions, softening, and the temperature actually needed.
- Tolerance during work: butter continuity as the thickness is reduced, and how it reacts to waiting times and to conditions in the production kitchen.
- The baked product: development, evenness of the layers, melt, aroma, and any leakage.
Run a trial with your reference formula and the same number of folds. If the butter needs different preparation, write it down: you will then be able to reproduce the conditions that give the result you want.
Melting during baking: butter melts before the dough fully sets
Milk fat melts gradually: its composition and crystalline organization determine how it behaves. The “melting point” given on a spec sheet helps characterize the product. During baking, the butter and the dough undergo several transformations, some in sequence and some at the same time.
In a croissant, the butter normally melts before the dough structure has fully set. The fat layers formed during lamination help keep the dough layers separate.
The gas from fermentation expands, and the steam produced from the water in the dough contributes to development. Starch gelatinization and protein changes then give the structure its strength; further baking dries it out.
A pool of butter therefore calls for examining lamination continuity, final proof, and baking together. Find the first stage at which the defect appears to choose the setting to correct.
In your LogiBake recipe steps, you can record the temperature of the butter and the détrempe during lamination, along with the final proof and bake you have validated. The team finds these benchmarks on the recipe card.
Explore recipe managementConcentrated butter: choosing the product and recalculating the formula
A concentrated butter with 99.8% fat contains very little water. Several technical products exist, including some designed for lamination. For puff pastry, choose a product specifically designed for lamination.
An industrial concentrated product has a composition and structure prepared for a defined use. Those of butter clarified in the production kitchen depend on how it was prepared: take this difference into account when substituting.
Example calculation based on fat: 500 g of 82% butter contributes 410 g of fat. To get the same amount with a 99.8% product, the calculation gives 410 ÷ 0.998 ≈ 410.8 g. Replacing the 500 g with 500 g of concentrated butter would contribute 499 g of fat, or 89 g more.
This calculation establishes the equivalence in fat. To adapt the recipe, continue the balance with the water and nonfat solids removed, then check the texture and the incorporation method. Each contribution must be handled separately.
Use the product for the applications listed on its spec sheet and validate the recipe after a trial. The spec sheet specifies its characteristics and storage conditions; the trial lets you assess aroma and texture in your product.
Choosing products according to what you make
| Production | Criteria to compare |
|---|---|
| Croissants and puff pastry | Plasticity with your détrempe, preparation, evenness of the layers, and melt after baking |
| Brioches, loaf cakes, and short doughs | Incorporation, aroma, texture, and behavior in the chosen method |
| Buttercreams and finishing preparations | Taste, suppleness, and stability at actual working and serving temperatures |
| Recipe using concentrated butter | Stated use, fat and water contribution, validated incorporation method |
To bring in a new butter, compare small documented batches: same starting recipe, weights, process, and tasting conditions. Note the adjustments needed and confirm the result on another batch.
Finally, compare the cost in the recipe actually adopted, the pack sizes, storage, and the losses observed. Weigh the cost per batch against the result obtained to decide which product to adopt.
LogiBake does not replace your expertise.
It gives you the tools to make the most of it.