Ingredient scienceFlours and grains

Gluten: how it forms and why it gives your bread its structure

Understand how water and mixing form gluten, so you can adjust hydration, mixing, and autolyse to get the crumb you want.

6 min read7 chapters
Table of contents(7 chapters)
1

Gliadins and glutenins: the proteins behind the network

Wheat flour already contains the gluten proteins. What develops while the dough is being made is their organization into a hydrated, viscoelastic network. Dry flour therefore does contain gluten in terms of its composition, even though it does not yet have the continuous network of a dough.

Two families of proteins play a major role in it:

  • Gliadins contribute in particular to deformability and extensibility.
  • Glutenins mainly contribute to resistance and elasticity.

Tenacity is resistance to deformation; extensibility is the ability to stretch before breaking; elasticity is the tendency to spring back after deformation. The behavior of the dough results from their balance, the nature of the proteins, and the process, not from two proportions assumed to be always equal.

Total protein content is useful, but on its own it measures neither the proteins’ baking quality nor the final strength of the dough.

2

Hydration: developing the network and adjusting consistency

Water allows the proteins to hydrate and plays a part in forming the network. It is also shared among the starch and the other components of the flour. A stiff dough can develop gluten: 55% is not a threshold at which the network appears.

For a dough made of flour, water, salt, and yeast, the hydration rate expresses the weight of water relative to the weight of flour. 650 g of water for 1,000 g of flour gives 65%. If the recipe contains a levain or a pre-fermented dough, also count the flour and water they bring.

In an enriched dough, the weight of whole eggs or milk is not entirely water: keep the percentage of these ingredients separate from a calculation of actual water content.

Adding water generally makes the dough softer, but it does not guarantee a more open crumb. Choose a consistency compatible with the flour, the fermentation, and the shaping, then check the volume and texture you get.

Good to know

Absorption depends in particular on protein, fiber, and damaged starch. Ask your miller for guidance values and check the consistency: the flour type or the protein content alone is not enough to set the water.

3

Mixing, rests, and folds: building strength

Mixing combines the ingredients, distributes the water, incorporates air, and develops the structure of the dough. The network also continues to form during rests; depending on the process, folds then contribute to its strength.

The pickup stage brings the ingredients together and blends them evenly. The mixing that follows depends on the mixer, the batch size, the flour, and the product. Minutes on first or second speed do not transfer directly from one machine to another.

To assess development, take a small piece and stretch it gradually: a thin membrane can tell you how continuous the network is. Cross-check this windowpane test with suppleness, strength, and temperature. A dough rich in bran particles does not necessarily give the same windowpane as a white dough.

The development you want when the dough leaves the mixer also depends on the planned bulk fermentation and folds. Mixing until you get the thinnest possible windowpane is not the goal for every product.

4

Undermixing or overmixing: cross-checking observations

Insufficient development can leave a dough with little cohesion. Excessive mixing, on the other hand, can cause a loss of strength after a phase in which the dough seemed better structured. The flour, the hydration, the equipment, and heat buildup all influence this behavior.

26°C is not a universal temperature at which the network breaks down. The final mixing temperature is a process target to define for the product and its fermentation.

ObservationWhat to check
Uneven dough, or dough that tears earlyHydration, mixing, rest time, and the development expected at this stage
Dough that loses strength after becoming structuredCumulative mechanical work, temperature, and the flour’s tolerance
Sticky or very slack doughWater, flour, temperature, and fermentation; this sign alone does not prove overmixing
Whiter crumb and muted aromaMixing intensity and oxidation, separate from diagnosing a breakdown of the network

Oxidation can modify the proteins and bleach pigments in the flour. It should not be confused with “gluten whitening” or taken as automatic proof of overmixing.

Good to know

Measure the temperature with a clean probe, in the center of the dough. A target of 24–26°C may suit some breads, but it must match your process. Adjust the mixing water based on the temperatures you measure and the mixer’s friction heat.

5

Autolyse: letting gluten form on its own

A strict autolyse means mixing flour and water alone (no salt, yeast, or levain — unlike a fermentolyse or a pre-fermented dough), then letting it rest, generally for 20 minutes to 1 hour as a starting point for trials depending on flour strength and hydration, before adding the remaining ingredients and mixing. During this rest, the proteins hydrate and passively begin forming the network, whereas an autolyse that is too long with weak or very high-extraction flour can slacken the dough through enzyme activity.

Autolyse changes the dough’s extensibility and how much mixing it needs. Compare the times and behavior of a control formula and a formula with autolyse, using the same flour and under the same conditions.

6

Salt, sugar, fat, and acidity: different effects

Ingredients affect structure, consistency, and fermentation at the same time. Their effect depends on the amount and on the order in which they are added.

  • Salt: contributes to dough strength and moderates fermentation. When it goes in depends on the process; it can be added at the start of mixing or after an autolyse. Avoid leaving yeast in direct contact with concentrated salt for a long time before mixing.
  • Sugar: changes water availability and, at high concentrations, slows fermentation. Adapt the formula and the yeast to the richness of the dough; routinely extending mixing does not resolve all the effects of sugar.
  • Fat: changes how the flour hydrates and the texture. For some brioches, the butter is added after the network has begun to develop; in pâte sablée, by contrast, sablage works the fat in from the start to limit gluten development.
  • Acidity: acts on proteins and enzymes. Over the course of fermentation, it can change dough strength markedly; observe the condition of the dough and how the levain is managed rather than diagnosing from sour taste alone.

A brioche and a sablé have different needs. The right order of incorporation is the one that gives the structure you want in the chosen formula.

In the LogiBake Calculator, baker’s percentages are expressed relative to the flour recognized in the recipe. They help you compare the proportions of salt, sugar, or butter; interpreting their effect still depends on the formula and your observations.

Explore recipe management
7

Three checks for comparing your batches

  1. Fix the weights and the basis for calculation. Record total flour, added water, and what the preferments contribute. Compare two batches made with the same flour and the same batch size.
  2. Observe development. Note speed, time, appearance, suppleness, and strength. If you are testing an autolyse, start with a defined time, for example 30 minutes, and compare it with a control batch.
  3. Measure the dough temperature. Adjust the water temperature according to the temperature of the flour, the production kitchen, and the heat generated by your equipment. The same water temperature does not suit every situation.

Then follow how the dough behaves during bulk fermentation, at shaping, and after baking. Change one parameter at a time and keep the trial conditions the same. These observations let you settle on a reproducible process, without promising a result after a fixed number of bakes.

Key takeaway

The quality of the gluten network depends on the flour’s proteins, the water, and the process. Mixing, rests, folds, and fermentation work together. Check weights and temperatures, observe how the dough holds at each stage, and keep the settings that suit the product you want.

Free online tool

Dough water temperature calculator

Calculate the water temperature based on your mixer and your temperatures.

Open the calculator

LogiBake does not replace your expertise.

It gives you the tools to make the most of it.